When Abortion is a Homicide of Self-Defense

By
Charlene Bader
Published On
February 6, 2018
When Abortion is a Homicide of Self-Defense

Every homicide justified by self-defense has one thing in common: fear.

"I was alone."

"I feared for my life."

"I was afraid they would hurt my family."

The person who shoots in self-defense -- oftentimes, a police officer -- warrants his actions by describing a genuine experience of fear, even when additional information reveals an unarmed victim, sometimes without criminal history or criminal intent. An innocent victim.

Fear, even unfounded fear, is used regularly as justification for homicides committed in self-defense.

Just as innovative police courses now empower officers to better negotiate fear, our society needs to better resource parents -- women, in particular -- to navigate the genuine fears of raising children in America.

Our society needs to better resource parents -- women, in particular -- to navigate the genuine fears of raising children in America.

My friend is a counselor in an abortion clinic.

She walks the here-and-now with women who just read a positive pregnancy test, and it's a crisis.

I believe that positive pregnancy tests should always and everywhere be a reason to celebrate.

She's held women's hands who know the fear of being one rent check short of homeless.

I say we can resource for this mom from within our parish. Maybe someone has a room to rent?

She's listened, as many women share their fears. Oftentimes, they have other children. They fiercely love their children, sacrificing much for them. And yet, in this unfamiliar situation, they are experiencing genuine fear.

I'll lose my job.

I can't afford daycare.

No one can help me.

If I don't work, my other children can't eat.

I was raped.

I don't have health insurance.

I can't raise a special needs child.

My husband is abusive.

My parents will kick me out.

I'm afraid my child would just be lost and abused in a broken foster care system.

♦♦♦

I push, in response, that we're working to change all of that. We can network. Maybe a family can help with childcare. Maybe a local doctor will help with prenatal care. There are food pantries! We will petition the legislature for better support for kids with special needs. Yes, our state needs better, more accessible, more affordable healthcare. I've heard families say that they'll personally adopt children who need a home, if the only other choice is abortion. I'll find them.

But all of my stammering is future tense and conditional. It's about stuff I want to see happen. It's about platforms I support that empower women who are mothers  by removing legitimate fears of parenthood.

This is now. And even though the child within her is unarmed and innocent, this mother is afraid. She has no back-up, she feels she has no other choice, and she's ready to pull the trigger.

And even though the child within her is unarmed and innocent, this mother is afraid.

If only we could remove the fear from this situation, so she's no longer afraid of the baby she carries.

She needs job protections, income stability, affordable child care, advocacy for sexual assault victims, community support whose actions are as loud as their promises, affordable and accessible maternity care, pediatric care, improved special needs services for children, affordable housing, a reformed foster care system...

Abortion doesn't need to be a homicide of self-defense.

We can help remove the fear.

Latest from the Blog

‘Cabrini’ Review: Despite Its Shortcomings, ‘Cabrini’ Highlights Our Responsibility to the Poor
Blog
/
Culture

‘Cabrini’ Review: Despite Its Shortcomings, ‘Cabrini’ Highlights Our Responsibility to the Poor

Emily Claire Schmitt
FemCatholic’s Women To Watch in 2024
Blog
/
Culture

FemCatholic’s Women To Watch in 2024

Augusta D'Ambrosio
“Mean Girls” (2024) Brings Lessons on Friendship and Feminism to a New Audience
Blog
/
Culture

“Mean Girls” (2024) Brings Lessons on Friendship and Feminism to a New Audience

Emily Claire Schmitt
Giving Up Alcohol Gave Me Freedom from Fearing Others’ Judgment
Blog
/
Culture

Giving Up Alcohol Gave Me Freedom from Fearing Others’ Judgment

Vicky Wolak Freeman
"The Color Purple" (2023) Highlights the Search for God in a Broken World
Blog
/
Culture

"The Color Purple" (2023) Highlights the Search for God in a Broken World

Emily Claire Schmitt
Dear Alana: Processing the Podcast
Blog
/
Culture

Dear Alana: Processing the Podcast

FemCatholic
Someone Inside You: The Use of Women’s Bodies in Possession Horror Films
Blog
/
Culture

Someone Inside You: The Use of Women’s Bodies in Possession Horror Films

Emily Claire Schmitt
5 Things That Need to Change for Our Country to be More Welcoming to New Life
Blog
/
Culture

5 Things That Need to Change for Our Country to be More Welcoming to New Life

Kelly Sankowski

Every homicide justified by self-defense has one thing in common: fear.

"I was alone."

"I feared for my life."

"I was afraid they would hurt my family."

The person who shoots in self-defense -- oftentimes, a police officer -- warrants his actions by describing a genuine experience of fear, even when additional information reveals an unarmed victim, sometimes without criminal history or criminal intent. An innocent victim.

Fear, even unfounded fear, is used regularly as justification for homicides committed in self-defense.

Just as innovative police courses now empower officers to better negotiate fear, our society needs to better resource parents -- women, in particular -- to navigate the genuine fears of raising children in America.

Our society needs to better resource parents -- women, in particular -- to navigate the genuine fears of raising children in America.

My friend is a counselor in an abortion clinic.

She walks the here-and-now with women who just read a positive pregnancy test, and it's a crisis.

I believe that positive pregnancy tests should always and everywhere be a reason to celebrate.

She's held women's hands who know the fear of being one rent check short of homeless.

I say we can resource for this mom from within our parish. Maybe someone has a room to rent?

She's listened, as many women share their fears. Oftentimes, they have other children. They fiercely love their children, sacrificing much for them. And yet, in this unfamiliar situation, they are experiencing genuine fear.

I'll lose my job.

I can't afford daycare.

No one can help me.

If I don't work, my other children can't eat.

I was raped.

I don't have health insurance.

I can't raise a special needs child.

My husband is abusive.

My parents will kick me out.

I'm afraid my child would just be lost and abused in a broken foster care system.

♦♦♦

I push, in response, that we're working to change all of that. We can network. Maybe a family can help with childcare. Maybe a local doctor will help with prenatal care. There are food pantries! We will petition the legislature for better support for kids with special needs. Yes, our state needs better, more accessible, more affordable healthcare. I've heard families say that they'll personally adopt children who need a home, if the only other choice is abortion. I'll find them.

But all of my stammering is future tense and conditional. It's about stuff I want to see happen. It's about platforms I support that empower women who are mothers  by removing legitimate fears of parenthood.

This is now. And even though the child within her is unarmed and innocent, this mother is afraid. She has no back-up, she feels she has no other choice, and she's ready to pull the trigger.

And even though the child within her is unarmed and innocent, this mother is afraid.

If only we could remove the fear from this situation, so she's no longer afraid of the baby she carries.

She needs job protections, income stability, affordable child care, advocacy for sexual assault victims, community support whose actions are as loud as their promises, affordable and accessible maternity care, pediatric care, improved special needs services for children, affordable housing, a reformed foster care system...

Abortion doesn't need to be a homicide of self-defense.

We can help remove the fear.

Want to see more in-depth content?

Explore Our Courses

Charlene Bader

Born and raised in Texas, Charlene enjoys teaching, editing, and writing while raising 5 boys (ages 3-9) with her husband, Wally. Charlene learned to love Scripture from her Baptist parents and liturgy from her Episcopal grandma. A personal interest in church history and social justice led to her conversion to Catholicism in 2003. In 2004, Charlene graduated from the University of North Texas with a degree in Communications. She’s worked in the arts, administration, and education in the non-profit, private, and public sectors, as a full-time working mom, part-time working mom, work-from-home mom, and homeschooling mom. She’s passionate about social justice, ecumenism, and helping others experience a personal, relevant connection to the Lord in their everyday lives. Charlene’s blog can be found at www.sunrisebreaking.com.

By clicking “Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.